Last year, my best Chasing Value recommendation was Aluminum Corp of China ADS (NYSE: ACH), which sailed from $22 per share to a 52-week high of $90.95. I will take credit for finding a winner, but I cannot in all honesty say that I thought it would more than quadruple -- that part was luck. (The original story was Chasing Value: Aluminum Corporation of China ADS, which I still think is worth a read today.)
If you acquired what is often referred to as Chalco (China Alum. Co.) anywhere near the time I recommended it and still own it you are probably still very content with only perhaps a 90% gain as the stock has come down some, closing last Friday May 9 at $40.98
Another of my recommendations was General Dynamics Corp (NYSE: GD), which closed Friday at $90.92. This one is only up a few percentage points from my starting point of $88 per share, but you will note, curiously, that it is only 3 cents off ACH's high. Given the market's bad year, a gain when the market is losing is a bigger plus than the casual observer would perceive. The defense sector has provided the anticipated market defense as I discussed.
The new earnings seasons kicks off tomorrow after the market closes when Alcoa Inc. (NYSE: AA) is scheduled to report first-quarter results.
Pittsburgh-based Alcoa has missed earnings estimates in only one quarter out of the past five. When the leading aluminum producer reported fourth-quarter results back in December, earnings of 36 cents per share beat the consensus of analysts surveyed by Thomson Financial by three cents, but were down from 74 cents per share in the same quarter of 2006. For this current quarter, analysts expect earnings of 50 cents per share.
Alcoa's full-year 2007 earnings per share of $2.60 missed estimates of $2.83, and were down from $2.96 for 2006. However, Alcoa also reported record revenue of $30.7 billion, as well as record income from continuing operations.
Alcoa's forecast earnings per share growth for the year is 9.85%, which is better than the industry average and the S&P 500. The consensus recommendation from analysts is to buy Alcoa, and has been for at least 90 days. The share price has been climbing from the 52-week low of $26.69 in January, and closed at $39.00 on Friday.
After hitting a one-year high of $48.77 in July, the stock hit a one-year low of $26.69 in January. AA opened this morning at $36.01. So far today the stock has hit a low of $35.71 and a high of $36.42. As of 10:25, AA is trading at $36.05, up 54 cents (1.5%). The chart for AA looks neutral and improving, while S&P gives the stock a positive 4 STARS (out of 5) buy rating.
For a bullish hedged play on this stock, I would consider an April bull-put credit spread below the $27.50 range. A bull-put credit spread is an options position that combines the purchase and sale of put options to hedge risk in case the stock doesn't do what you think but still leverage nice returns. For this particular trade, we will make a 5.3% return in just two months as long as AA is above $27.50 at April expiration. Alcoa would have to fall by more than 23% before we would start to lose money.
AA hasn't been below $27.50 by more than a few cents in the past year and has shown support around $34 recently. This trade could be risky if the US economy continues to worsen, but even if that happens, this position could be protected by the support the stock might find around $28, where the stock bottomed out in January.
Brent Archer is an options analyst and writer at Investors Observer. At publication time, Brent neither owns nor controls positions in AA, ACH or RTP.
In one of my recent posts on stock pricing, I received a comment from one of our more acerbic readers, who asks some good questions once he simmers down. He wonders why investors have not bid up the share price of Alcoa Inc. (NYSE: AA):
"How come nobody has the hots for ALCOA? It is very cheap. . . There is mining stock merger-mania yet nobody is buying ALCOA in anticipation of it occurring to ALCOA as well. Are we gonna wait until it is too late?"
First of all, I should remind everyone that the price of a stock on any given day is a myth. It is worse than a myth, it is just a fleeting moment in time. I would call it semi-arbitrary most of the time.
Alcoa closed yesterday at $34.06, having a trailing P/E ratio of 11.5. That falls between its 52 week low of $26.69 and its high of $48.77. Also worthy of note, Alcoa has a yield of 2% which is about 10% higher than your average S&P stock. This seems positive.
Perhaps my friend is on to something. Alcoa is off its high considerably and has a lower P/E and higher yield then any of the indices. But its ROE of 15 and ROIC of 11 are all too average, not exceptional -- and these are important considerations. The P/B of 1.89 also seems average but the P/S of 1.03 looks very appealing.
One of our readers commented recently that I had earned his respect because I always tracked and posted my bad picks not just the good picks. I have been told this often but it is not so uncommon in better publications. Barron's weekly and Fortune Magazine both do the same. It's only fair, and should be standard operating procedure. I have not seen James Cramer do it but then he makes thousands of recommendations so how can he track anything?
I also think that in a blog you have the opportunity to establish a dialogue with readers and might even learn something. I have learned plenty from readers and colleagues alike. So having exposed some of my failings in the past month I thought I would look back and and review some of my successful picks.
When I posted Chasing value: Aluminum Corporation of China ADS eleven months ago in March, ACH was $22.98. It closed yesterday at $39.03 for a 70% gain. It had reached a 52-week high of $90.95 in between. We took some money off the table at $88 and are now playing with the 'house money'. This one has worked out great.
HNP pays a sizable 3.6% dividend yield and has plenty of room to run. It has come down a lot with the rest of the inflated Chinese stock market, but this one is not threatened by competition and is a good long-term value. It is the largest utility company in China, entrenched in government projects and receives support that would be full of conflicts of interest in a western economy.
I have made the case recently that electric utilities have been great investments over the long term in Serious Money: Electric utilities are the place to be, and I am still a believer. China's growth curve will continue to dwarf that of the United States. It takes electricity for all the things you know about and many you do not. I am not sure that the average investor is aware for example that the production of aluminum consumes a lot of electricity. And it is being used in increasing amounts as reducing energy costs often means reducing weight.
Aluminum is used in windows, cars, planes, electronics, and this is a great trend to follow as well. One of my top picks last year was Aluminum Corp of China ADS (NYSE: ACH), and I would have included it here if not for its sky-high price.
To quote one of my college professors (with thick Chicago accent) "Ya pays yer nickle 'n ya takes ya bes' shot." This year I wrote over 200 stories and reviewed even more stocks. Going over all of this material I came up with the ones listed here as my four best and four worst of the year.
If you would have acquired these eight stocks you would be up 21.79%, about double the NASDAQ, triple the DJIA and 550% over the S&P 500. Had I followed the advice of some of my more astute readers or been more cynical about the forthrightness and leadership in the financial sector, I would have had a really smashing year. As it was, I cannot complain. I think this coming year I will have to analyze some of the feedback even more closely than I have in the past -- keep those comments coming!
Here are the results of the indices from December 28, 2006 through December 27, 2007 for comparison:
You all can worry about whatever you want to worry about. You can follow the bulls or bears, day traders or CD holders, Wall Street pundits or the guy next door, it does not matter to me. I am looking for opportunity in the rubble.
If you are a true investor, you have a watch list -- when there is fear and negativity in the market like there has been the past few days, there will be opportunities. It is not a time to jump in with both feet, and it is not a time to speculate. It is a time to pick and choose among the companies and stocks you know well.
I would like to own more Intuitive Surgical (NASDAQ: ISRG) but it has run up so fast it has escaped my grasp, although I sense an opportunity is in the wings. I would like to own more Anglo American PLC (NYSE: AAUK) but it jumped up after recent acquisition talks in the mining industry and has not settled down yet. And it may not, but I will be patient. My regular readers know I love Huaneng Power Intl ADS (NYSE: HNP), which hardly moved today but has come down significantly in the past week, and that is very, very tempting.
Aluminum Corp. of China Ltd. (NYSE: ACH) stock is slumping today as aluminum futures are off by more than 2% as are other industrial metals like copper. Investors may also be locking in their gains after Friday's big positive move. If you think this stock won't be rising too far in the coming months, then it could be a good time to look at a bearish hedged play on ACH
The stock has been climbing steadily all year, hitting a one-year high of $76.99 on Friday. This morning, ACH opened at $74.00. So far today the stock has hit a low of $72.78 and a high of $75.33. As of 11:00, ACH is trading at $74.92, down $1.93 (-2.5%). The chart for ACH looks bullish but slightly deteriorating, while S&P gives the stock a neutral 3 STARS (out of 5) hold rating.
For a bearish hedged play on this stock, I would consider an October bear-call credit spread above the $85 range. A bear-call credit spread is an options position that combines the purchase and sale of call options to hedge risk in case the stock doesn't do what you think but still leverages nice returns. For this particular trade, we will make a 6.4% return in 2 weeks as long as ACH is below $85 at October expiration. Chalco would have to rise by more than 33% before we would start to lose money. The stock has never been above $77 and would have to jump by over 14% in less than two weeks to cause a problem.
Brent Archer is an options analyst and writer at Investors Observer. DISCLOSURE: Mr. Archer owns and/or controls diversified portfolios of long and short stock and option positions that may include holdings in companies he writes about. At publication time, Brent neither owns nor controls positions in ACH.
Today Alcoa Inc. (NYSE: AA) announced some restructuring plans that will trim down (SELL) some under-performing consumer packaging and automotive castings divisions. It will be taking some charges to the tune of $845 million as well, and intends to gear up for expansion into higher margin areas. Alcoa also said it raised cash by selling its 7% stake in Chalco, the Aluminum Corp China ADS (NYSE: ACH) and bringing in $2 billion dollars on what was initially a $200 million investment -- "A ten bagger."
It is this latter decision that is not smart, and without further explanation from management I have to question selling a winner. If you look at all of the things that Alcoa did in the last 10 years you will find that the Chalco investment was the smartest, and more importantly, the most profitable, thing it has done. For many years Alcoa stock has been adrift. Since it sold the stock it has only gone up further and as I write these words and look at the price now, ACH is trading up over 5% more to $75.70.
I think you all have gone mad if you are buying stocks today just because the market is moving up, or you are planning on federal rate cuts yet to be announced, or Hilary Kramer or James Cramer said so, or you are afraid the train is leaving the station without you, or your stock broker or palm reader has become bullish. There is only one reason to buy stocks and that is to make money and secure your future for the long run. To do that you need to have solid reasons that can be accounted for and demonstrated to have a high degree of probablity. I did not see that today.
A friend of mine asked me today whether they should sell their shares of Google Inc. (NASDAQ: GOOG) and take profits after it's recent runnup. I told them I had no idea whether to buy, sell or hold. There was no concrete data that has been released since it's last quarterly report (after which it dropped by $50 in one day) so to me it is all wild speculation. If you believe that the rate cuts are good for the overall market which includes Google then perhaps you can hang your hat on that -- I won't be.
I have been touting Huaneng Power ADS (NYSE: HNP) for a long time and those that paid heed to my comments made a ton of money with me, but even though I love this stock I am not promoting it today after it's 45% jump in the last six weeks Volatile Market picks: Huaneng Power (HNP) is my pick for the next 50 years. I like to buy on dips as I wrote when it was down 20% off its high not when it is screaming forward to new highs. I think patience is in order.
This is the fourth update on the stock price status of the first seventeen Chasing Value companies. Closing prices are from September 14, 2007.
The first quarter produced amazing results but the second quarter was downright sad. No one will be surprised to see that anything touching constuction or finance took a bath. I own most of these stocks, so if you do too, I feel your pain. Anyone considering my commentary should "do their homework" too, as James Cramer says on his Mad Money TV show. These recommendations are from the first and second quarter 2007 and I have linked to the original stories.
Cemex sank with the continuous reports of the deteriorating housing market in the United States. In the meantime it continues to move forward with the integration of Rinker, the largest supplier of construction materials in Australia. This makes Cemex the largest in the world and sets the stage for continued growth in Southeast Asia. It also is continuing to focus on reducing debt.
Of all the stocks I have written about in the Chasing Value section, I feel that this one suffered the most from guilt by association. I believe it was fairly valued before and it is on sale now. This company, with it's PEG ratio at .83 and lowered, P/E, P/S, P/B (SEE: AOL Money & Finance) has a ROE over 22 and pays about a 2% dividend yield.
It just keeps rolling along. "China Inc." keeps beating it's own trade records. It posted a trade surplus of $24.97 billion for August, up from $18.8 billion a year earlier, the customs administration said today, according to CNBC. That's not all, China just passed Canada as our number one trading partner, which although not unexpected, is just another example of the export steam roller that shows no signs of slowing down. All this despite numerous product safety recalls.
We are buying Chinese products at an ever increasing rate. It should also be noted that they are buying our goods and services at an ever increasing rate too. The problem is that they are getting the better end of the deal for now and the gap between imports and exports is increasing. When I wrote Stop blaming China - partners win, whiners lose, I addressed some of these issues, and readers added many more. Some categorized the situation as a Chinese trade war but I take exception to this. I think we are facing very strong Chinese competition and the question is are we prepared?
Our trade deficit is only part of the problem. While China is creaming us with very low labor rates and worse environmental, safety, and legal (piracy) issues, all of which need to improve to level the playing field, there are other issues that we should fear more. That is our failure to compete in producing math, science, and engineering graduates or even having a plan to stimulate improving our graduate rates in these areas. If we do not remain strong in these areas we will be exporting more and more engineering jobs, and worse, the things China imports now might slow down drastically. Many of the things China manufactures now are designed and engineered in the United States. Nothing guarantees this situation will remain as is. It is all very fluid and will become more so. We face the same dilemma with regards to India and eastern Europe.
Aluminum Corp of China (NYSE: ACH) volume & volatility spikes on wide price swings. ACH is engaged in bauxite mining, alumina refining and aluminum smelting. ACH is recently up $10.73 to $64.81. ACH closed at $37.04 on 8/16/07. ACH call option volume of 6,490 contracts compares to put volume of 4,671 contracts. ACH September option implied volatility of 88 is above its 26-week average of 47 according to Track Data, suggesting larger price risk.
Open Text (NASDAQ: OTEX) volatility Elevated at 80 into 8/30 EPS & Outlook. OTEX develops, markets, sells, and supports enterprise content management solutions. OTEX is recently down $0.29 to $19.98. OTEX will report EPS on August 30th. Canaccord Adams says: :We maintain our Hold recommendation and U.S. $18 target based on our Discounted Cash Flow analysis." OTEX September option implied volatility of 80 is above its 26-week average of 50 according to Track Data, suggesting larger risk.
Corus (NASDAQ: CORS) volatility elevated on exposure to commercial real estate. CORS is an active commercial real estate lender nationwide, specializing in condominium, hotel, office and apartment loans. CORS had outstanding commercial real estate loans and construction commitments of $8 billion as of 6/30/07. CORS over all option implied volatility of 60 is above its 26-week average of 49 according to Track Data, suggesting larger risk.
Daily options Update is provided by Stock Specialist Paul Foster of theflyonthewall.com.
The stock market has stabilized somewhat in recent days, but I still have a very pessimistic outlook for stocks, as I explain in this video. I think stocks could fall another 25%.
Internationally, I suggest looking to China plays like Aluminum Corp. of China Limited (ADR) (NYSE: ACH) and global environmental plays like Veolia Environment (ADR) (NYSE: VE). Finally, I offer a stock tip: Darling International Inc. (ASE: DAR) is a little-known environmental company which gets paid to collect waste like animal by-products and cooking grease and turns it into biodeisel which it then sells. Enjoy the video!
Last year, my best Chasing Value recommendation was Aluminum Corp of China ADS (NYSE: ACH), which sailed from $22 per share to a 52-week high of $90.95. I will take credit for finding a winner, but I cannot in all honesty say that I thought it would more than quadruple -- that part was luck. (The original story was Chasing Value: Aluminum Corporation of China ADS, which I still think is worth a read today.)
The new earnings seasons kicks off tomorrow after the market closes when 
You all can worry about whatever you want to worry about. You can follow the bulls or bears, day traders or CD holders, Wall Street pundits or the guy next door, it does not matter to me. I am looking for opportunity in the rubble.
Today 
It just keeps rolling along. "China Inc." keeps 
Aluminum Corp of China
Oil hits record $127.43 on supply concerns, raised Goldman forecast
Icahn's 'shock and awe' on Yahoo -- a gutsy play
Housing starts surprisingly rise in April on apartment construction
